Matthew Schaefer Signed 16x20 1st OT Goal Photo Framed UDA COA Plaque Islanders

This Matthew Schaefer signed New York Islanders display features a 16x20 photo commemorating his first career overtime goal, with Schaefer pictured in his Islanders uniform and his autograph signed prominently in silver ink.

The photo has been professionally framed with Islanders-themed blue and orange matting, along with two Islanders medallions and a custom plaque identifying Matthew Schaefer – New York Islanders #48 – 2026 Calder Trophy Recipient. The complete framed piece is ready to hang and makes an excellent centerpiece for any Islanders collection.

The autograph is authenticated by Upper Deck Authenticated (UDA), with the corresponding hologram and authentication documentation included.

A great piece celebrating an early milestone in Schaefer’s career and a standout collectible for fans of the New York Islanders and one of the NHL’s top young players.

Scott Stimell, the President of Cardboard Memories, is a nationally respected autograph expert who is a former consultant for JSA and has been featured on many shows as an autograph expert. 

We have an actual physical bricks and mortar store Cardboard Memories for over 34 years we are located in Commack, Long Island, New York 

We're in a new location at 114 Commack rd in the Meat Farms Shopping Center

COME CHECK US OUT !!!

Owner Scott Stimell was recently featured on the Netflix series, the king of collectibles you can see Scott in the first episode which aired in April of 2023

New York winners pay 8.75% sales tax

All others pay their state taxes.

jt back room on shelf