Skip to product information
1 of 24

Matthew Schaefer Signed Premium Islanders Jersey 1st Overall Pick 2025 Auto UDA

Matthew Schaefer Signed Premium Islanders Jersey 1st Overall Pick 2025 Auto UDA

Regular price $1,199.99
Regular price $0.00 Sale price $1,199.99
Sale Sold out
Quantity
View full details

Description

Amazing Matthew Schaefer hand-signed New York Islanders blue Fanatics Premium jersey, featuring his autograph on the back number 8 along with the special inscription “1st Overall Pick 2025.” The autograph and inscription were witnessed and fully authenticated by Upper Deck and come with a matching Upper Deck certificate of authenticity and numbered hologram affixed directly to the jersey.

This is an authentic Fanatics Premium jersey in size 52 (Mens Large), featuring fully stitched names, numbers, and logos, along with a sewn-in fight strap. The jersey measures approximately 22 inches across the chest (pit to pit) and comes complete with its original Fanatics tags, Upper Deck authentication paperwork, and Upper Deck memorabilia box.

Selected 1st overall in the 2025 NHL Draft, Schaefer made an immediate impact with the Islanders, putting together a historic rookie season in 2025-26. He recorded 23 goals and 59 points, tying the NHL record for goals by a rookie defenseman and becoming the youngest player in league history to win the Calder Memorial Trophy as NHL Rookie of the Year. Schaefer has carried that momentum into the 2026-27 season with another outstanding start, quickly establishing himself as one of hockey’s brightest young stars.

A fantastic collectible featuring the Islanders’ franchise defenseman, with the added significance of his 2025 first overall draft pick inscription. This is a great opportunity to own an Upper Deck authenticated piece of memorabilia from one of the NHL’s most exciting young players.

Please review all photos for the exact jersey, autograph, inscription, authentication, and overall condition.

Scott Stimell, the President of Cardboard Memories, is a nationally respected autograph expert who is a former consultant for JSA and has been featured on many shows as an autograph expert.


We have an actual physical bricks and mortar store Cardboard Memories for over 34 years we are located in Commack, Long Island, New York

COME CHECK US OUT !!!


Owner Scott Stimell was recently featured on the Netflix series, the king of collectibles you can see Scott in the first episode which aired in April of 2023


New York winners pay 8.75% sales tax

All others pay their state taxes.

MS e storage